Thread: Jolla Tablet
View Single Post
Posts: 172 | Thanked: 353 times | Joined on Nov 2014
#438
Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
Judging from today's MWC hands on videos, I can say I am quite disappointed by the changes
Same here.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
With SailfishOS 2.0, the homescreen is landscape friendly, which means that the home screens are now horizontal, instead of being vertical (like it is now on the phone).
I just hope the landscape is not "forced" in the tablet like portrait is now on the phone. Landscape does not interest me that much, since I hardly ever use any phones or tablets in landscape (photos/videos don't count). However, those rare times that I do I feel landscape should be fully supported, too. The split screen feature may change my views about landscape use but that shall be seen later.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
Jolla solved it by reducing the number of cover actions to one (the reasoning is quite unclear) and changing the trigger to tapping (see this video) the area of the cover where the icon is.
This probably bothers me the most. The sliding has been an innovative feature and I would have loved to see the possibility to also up/down slide for more functions, but even if not, 2 is way more useful than one.
The covers + their sliding functions have also often been the most impressing feature while showing the phone use to others.

What I don't really get is how come horizontal swiping is supposed to be such a big problem that it is not possible to keep the sliding action in covers? The way I use the actions even now is hold&slide anyway, not plain swipe like one does while changing views.
(There is also the relatively wide gap between the cover rows that maybe could've been an option to use as the "swipe area" even though not the best idea, I'm sure).

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
Not only that - currently when you tap on an app cover, you can be sure it will open exactly where you left it. In Sailfish 2.0, you need to pay attention where you are tapping, because you may trigger an action you didn't intend to.
Exactly. Also the new aim&tap for a function is really a big step back from the relaxed cover slide with much bigger area. And I hate it.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
I think that it would make much more sense to convert the action gesture to a vertical one, which would make even more sense than now, because it could resemble pulldown/pushup menus.
This would've been a more preferable choice to the single tap.
Also, there would've been certain appealing symmetry (to me anyway) that when in portrait, slide the covers left/right and when in landscape, slide up/down.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
I certainly hope these changes won't make it to the phone, because the inconvenience would be even greater there. I understand the changes towards the landscape-friendly UI, but don't fix what ain't broken.
I totally share this hope with you. Speaking of covers, the functionality is already in my muscle memory so I'd hate to start learning to aim & tap instead.
 

The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to tmi For This Useful Post: