View Single Post
handful's Avatar
Posts: 1,412 | Thanked: 594 times | Joined on Aug 2005 @ Recife, Brazil
#140
Hi Brontide,

Thanks for the feedback. Most of the topics you touched have already been discussed / explained / solutions demonstrated here, but I'm glad to received because this is the data I use to priorize / change things.

So, even having the answers spreads in the threads I will answer again:

Originally Posted by brontide View Post
A few things.

1) The download manager didn't seem to install correctly and the place where you would add the feeds won't accept a paste.
What device are you using? Did you try hitting the menu button -> paste? when the keyboard is open it should do that even in the screen keyboard.

Anyways, the newest canola tuning gives you an small addition to the browser that let you add without copying and pasting. Even if you decided to do that, it's completely possible AFAIK.
take a look at mike's guide here




2) Podcasts should be automatically bookmarked. If I have to pause I want it to pick up where I left off.
Yes, this was a mandatory thing since the beginning, but first we needed to make sure :
a. you are able to "safely" subscribe to your feeds (I think we are supporting most of them now )

b. Download manager should be trustable (it took a lot of work but it's way better for beta6)

c. DM should support queues.

After that the next would be implemeting the more needed playaback options, and bookmark the last played point is happening. It was bookmarking only if you didn't leave canola. Now it will save your position for every episode. If not available on next release (coming in a couple of days) it will be on the second (coming in 2 to 4 weeks, due to the Bossa conference)

But, it doesn't end here, and we are looking forward: after that we will include : dowload all (from a feed) pause all, schedule downloads, and more options that are in the podcast backlog.

3) When I pick a playlist to play I don't want to have to select a song as well. I should be able to just pick the playlist and hit play.
Yeah, this was "known" and Morpheuz is trying to figure out how to do it without being a hack. As we tried to create our infrastructure so easy to develop on top, the playback and the media engine still a little bit too complicated to deal with the underlying media renderes, but we will solve thi. Not only for playlist but for the "play random". Should start playing already. This is really a annoying thing (I'm a random mode guy)

4) Still trying to figure out why some tracks sync'ed with 'synctunes' on the Mac show up as not there on canola
I, and the design we use mac, and synctunes... I think the relation is not there, but maybe on the ID tags. We are improving release by release (people have noticed) and what we can do is : send us some of the files that canola doesn't find? We will add to our "test media card" and make sure it appears (not by hack of course, but finding the reason it's not coming in the scanner) send me a PV(private message) that I will send you my personal email (it's my username on gmail ) : )


5) Consistency issue... I love the interface, but what is that icon(s) up in the upper right corner. All the other icons seem to represent something obvious or do something interesting.
Yeah, this was posted with more detail on my blog. here

Resuming : we had nice plans for it, and it was suppose to be a "task switcher" and you would understand the icon the first time you touch it. BUT we saw that in the near future the TS would not happen, so we decided to focus on the other important things, and left there only the "playing now" indicator. That helps you jump back to the playing now screen. But even that doesn't justify a button solely for that, so our plans is to transform it on a "notification area" but no plugin (but the playing) uses it now. So, it is indeed a "mistake" on the consistency side, but we are (sadly) aware of it, and we will try to fix once we get the bugs ironed out and some plugins that needs it



6) I find it very hard to scroll, I don't know exactly why. For some reason it likes to select rather than start to scroll.
[/quote]

Yeah, Mike (the one I sent you the link a little bit up) talked to me for a couple of hours on messenger about that. Of course I could enter the merits of the whole device's screen sensitivity but this is not the point.

The point is: this kind of screen (I assume here) is not the best thing to do what we are doing. Why? Because you need to apply pressure and keep the pressure.

So: if you touch, (it gets a press) and when you drag up or down your finger... if the pressure you're making is lighter to the point that the screen is not "felling" it anymore.. than it will be taken as a click : / because your finger was down and up on an same position (with a small, 5pixel boundarie). We can avoid that, but then clicking would be Amazingly hard, so it's complicated.

BUT I'm not saying that is your fault because maybe you are doing "soft" presses, but it's that we (the software) need points on the screen, if you don't do them : / we cannot "guess", and what happens is that you are really not "dragging the finger, slightly pressing the screen, you are just touching it superficially on the second stage of your dragging movement : /

ALSO: there's imperfections and problems with our implementations, but I must say here, that's why canola is not running on window mode, that's why canola has animation, that's why we are trying to be really different from the other gtk based apps. Because we are experimenting, and we will for sure get thing wrongs in the way, but as people have noticed, we have been trying to improve them like crazy

So, please do a test using something that creates more pressure (your finger nail) or even your stylus... and see how it works (if the screen is receiveing the touches) we will try to improve it :/ but I think there will be still some miss clicks : /

again, thanks for the time writing the suggestion, we are reall taking them into account!

Marcelo
__________________
Marcelo Eduardo
www.marceloeduardo.com
----------------------------
OpenBossa Labs @ INdT, Recife Brazil
http://openbossa.indt.org
 

The Following User Says Thank You to handful For This Useful Post: