In my opinion i would go with the nokia being that its sybian series 60 based. Meaning lots of toys and apps to install. And besides that motorola S@#$%^&*CKS! Also the nokia will stay charged longer and charge faster than the motos for some reason. I had a 3650 i loved to death, only reason i got rid of it was it didnt support EDGE data. I replaced it with a moto V551 which was faster for data but was junk in every other way. Wish i had a dime for every dropped call with the V551. Oh and i had the first RAZR befor the V551, the RAZR was slower on the data network so i exchanged it for the V551.