View Single Post
Posts: 63 | Thanked: 4 times | Joined on Feb 2008
#133
Originally Posted by benny1967 View Post
Neither styling widgets nor adding transparency will help you getting an existing desktop application to the tablet. It should be done with as little changes as possible, that's the whole point.

Also, neither styling widgets nor adding transparency will make for a better user experience (in general; I admit there are exceptions). Consistency is one of the most important points in user interfaces, and not using stock widgets but styling your own instead brings inconsistency. (When I say "consistency", I mean consistency not only within an application, but throughout the whole platform and, even more, across platforms. The user knows certain concepts from the desktop, and its a good thing to try to reproduce these in phones, tablets, PDAs or any other computer-like devices. Nobody wants to learn how to operate a new device from scratch.)
I think those advocating changes in the UI are hoping these updates to the UI would take place at a system level and not just on a per application basis - ie, our tablets implementation of Hildon gets revamped so therefore all applications making use of Hildon would be updated. See the first post's reference to Matchbox. This in turn shouldn't add any extra time to the process of Hildonizing existing desktop apps for use on the tablets.