Most people here are doing this as a hobby i assume. And so do i. And i prefer so spend this time coding instead doing organizational stuff.

I just saw several "lets find the best software" things in form of "pearls", "killer-apps", "remarkable maemo projects", "freemantle stars" etc. On the other hand i just don't see a single well maintained list of nice, recently updated and overall beautiful apps. I see a discrepancy here and i am still sure that a single such collection might be better than all those different lists, even if there's a reason for having these seperate and slightly different ones. Especially if there's a lack of manpower to maintain such lists.

Having a nice list would be something worth getting your software in. It would be a motivation for developers. Seeing many listings of varying quality and with entries of mixed quality imho doesn't encourage developers to get their software into one of them.