View Single Post
GeneralAntilles's Avatar
Posts: 5,478 | Thanked: 5,222 times | Joined on Jan 2006 @ St. Petersburg, FL
#121
Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
If Nokia wants a successful open source product, they need to be much more open. No two ways about it. As that's not happening, I'm going to use my N800 until it breaks . . .
But it is happening. Perhaps you weren't here two years ago, but Nokia's make great leaps and bounds since then and continues to make even more progress. Now, you could argue that it's not happening fast enough, but that's a separate issue from "not happening" at all.

Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
but develop for Android for the future because it will provide a good choice of devices.
What makes you think Maemo wont offer a good choice of devices? There've been more than a few hints lately along the lines of multiple device choices. Besides, if you want open (in all meanings of the word), Android doesn't really seem like the right choice.

Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
It's a sad but necessary decision for me.
Why? Did I miss a memo about the world ending?

Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
Back in July several people said "Just wait for the Maemo summit, something awesome is going to happen" but it didn't. There's still nothing more than "Trust us". No way. Trust has to be earned, not blindly demanded.
Er, it didn't? As far as I remember we found out about OMAP3 and HSPA in the next tablet, and quite a lot of information about Fremantle and its roadmap was revealed. The certainly sounds like something to me.

Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
There's still nothing more than "Trust us". No way.
Did you miss the pre-alpha? Or the slew of bugs that have been resolved lately? Or the continued roadmapping on the wiki? The alpha's just around the corner, and the beta after that. I think you'd be pretty safe betting on a hardware announcement mixed in there somewhere.

Which all stacks up to quite a lot more than "just trust us". Again, you could claim that it's not enough, but you certainly can't claim it's nothing more hot air.

Originally Posted by eiffel View Post
Trust has to be earned, not blindly demanded.
They've delivered 3 fantastic devices so far, what leads you to believe they can't deliver a fourth?

To me, it really all sounds like a lot of melodramatic sensationalism that's hardly worth wasting on stupid software platform.
__________________
Ryan Abel
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to GeneralAntilles For This Useful Post: