View Single Post
daperl's Avatar
Posts: 2,427 | Thanked: 2,986 times | Joined on Dec 2007
#146
Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles View Post
...other than observing friends, family, and coworkers), but I'd say very few people ever upgrade their computers. They're much more likely to simply purchase new machines.

Accepting that, how much sense do you think it would make for Nokia to make feature(s) like cellular data modular? Not much, I'd say. It's an awful large compromise to ask of the vast majority of users who will never, ever take advantage that modularity.
I have nothing to say about family, friends and upgrading. If I tried, my head would come off.

I seem to have too much to say about everything else, but I'll try to keep that from happening and instead I'll just make these strange random remarks.

If I had cellular technology tightly coupled with a primary computing device, my feeling would be that I would have a sub-optimal joining of 2 different industries. My opinion is that the computing industry and the communications industry should be loosely coupled at best. Especially in my hardware. <an oldy but a goody Nokia example>How would you like to be an n810 WiMAX owner with the equivalent of a dead rat inside?</an oldy but a goody Nokia example>

I own my cell phone outright, but because of its tight coupling with my service provider, it seems like a leased device, no different than my DVR and my cable modem. I don't think twice about this; they serve their purposes just fine.

And lastly, modular would put the mobile back in mobile.

Let's propose something else. What if, instead of a costly (to the customer) modular option Nokia offered several different devices for the Maemo platform. Each with a different set of options, some lower-end, some higher (much like Nokia's current cellular phone lineup).

That way, you could pick the device that suits you (say, the lower-end $250 tablet without 3G, accelerometers, FM RX/TX, GPS, or a hardware keyboard etc.) and somebody else could pick the device that suits them ($600, all the fixin's, hardware keyboard, etc.) and you're both happy without having to deal with the modularity compromise (which is a big one to swallow on mobile devices).
Well, sure. Sounds like car shopping. But I must warn you, 2 of my last 4 auto purchases were made-to-order directly from the manufacturer. I got exactly what I wanted. I'm guessing your talking about something a little less personal.
__________________
N9: Go white or go home