View Single Post
luca's Avatar
Posts: 1,137 | Thanked: 402 times | Joined on Sep 2007 @ Catalunya
#41
Originally Posted by maacruz View Post
Ah, my little grasshopper, please pay attention.
The visual usability of GUI is affected by several factors:
- The screen: the new theme colors are almost unbearable in my desktop (big high luminance and high resolution screen) while much easier in the n810. Screen resolution and size affect the available space and layout.
While I agree that the new theme is better on the tablet, I've no problem with my other machine (a 1680x1050 lcd screen): I don't spend all day reading the titles (though I don't find them too bad), and black on white is the combination I prefer.

Originally Posted by maacruz View Post
- The system fonts: bolder fonts make orange and gray text more readable, since the contrast is increased. On the other hand, the need of bigger fonts in the small screen causes the "right bar on top" problem.
- The room illumination: the screen background must not have excessive contrast with the room background. The eye can't be adapted to dark and light at the same time.
So, basically, are you saying that a dark theme would be better in a dimly lit room, while a black-on-white theme is only good in well lit rooms? Sorry, I don't buy it, you can adjust the backlight intensity to match the room illumination, and black-on-white is still more readable.

Originally Posted by maacruz View Post
- And,most important, the eye of the beholder, and, you see, it is not a question of beauty, but there are such thing as old people, color blindness, macular degeneration, and many other eye diseases, so what may appear fine to you, might be unbearable to other people.
My eyes aren't particularly good (I'm 43 and myopic), but I do know they ache if I look at a white-on-black (or generally bright-on-dark) page.
When I was younger I had no problem staring during hours at a green-phosphor crt (green on black). Besides, there was no alternative

Originally Posted by maacruz View Post
And that is why "one size fits all" is so a bad idea, and the first rule of ergonomics/usability is to allow the system to be adjusted to the user needs and not the other way around.
So, my little grasshopper, this is why so much people ask for a choice.
I'm not disagreeing with you on this, I was just disagreeing to the blunt affirmation that this is an unusable eyesore: it isn't for everybody.
I agree that choice is good (in fact, if I hadn't the choice in the previous version to select the classic theme, I wouldn't have endured this forums for a long time, I already think that forums are a PITA without having to also hurt my eyes to follow one).
 

The Following User Says Thank You to luca For This Useful Post: