View Single Post
johnkzin's Avatar
Posts: 1,878 | Thanked: 646 times | Joined on Sep 2007 @ San Jose, CA
#63
Originally Posted by deadmalc View Post
I could be wrong but I thought the reason that the N810 Wimax died, was because everyehere else except the US already has a reasonable mobile network suitable for data transfer?
The US has one. This isn't about 3G, this is about the emergence of 4G. The N810 WiMAX is basically a 4G device ... without a reasonably deployed 4G network to utilize. That's true whether you're talking about the US or Europe. The only decent deployment of WiMAX isn't even WiMAX, it's WiBro, in S. Korea.

The N810 WiMAX didn't fail because the US didn't have good enough 3G coverage, it failed because the WORLD wasn't ready for 4G, so a 4G device was incredibly premature. An N810 GSM/WCDMA device would probably have done a TON better (in the US and Europe) than the N810 WiMAX did.

The reason why this device will probably be OK is that a) it'll probably work just fine in Samsung's home country (S. Korea), and by the time it reaches the US, there will probably be a more solid WiMAX deployment to sell it into. And the WiMAX provider here will probably show it more love, since it's a WinMO device, as well.

when they can make do with the current roll outs and investments?

(I know there is one place in the UK with wimax, but the big roll out that was supposed to happen, just didn't)

In which case there is little point in having wimax?
The issue isn't "GSM vs WiMAX", and whether or not current investments are good enough. It's about the 4G protocol war (WiMAX vs LTE). The lack of adoption of WiMAX in the EU didn't happen because "we're good with WCDMA/UMTS". It happened because LTE became the direction everyone in the EU decided to go for the next generation. If everyone's deploying LTE for 4G, then WiMAX becomes a moot deployment.

(if there's one thing I give credit to the EU for, in this arena, it's that they're very consistent about this -- the US is rather schitzophrenic about it with EVDO and WCDMA, but 4G will be less so, with almost everyone going LTE over WiMAX).
__________________
My Personal Blog