View Single Post
sachin007's Avatar
Posts: 2,041 | Thanked: 1,066 times | Joined on Mar 2006 @ Houston
#92
Originally Posted by nilchak View Post
While there is nothing against having a mobile platform mature enough to provide a better browser and browsing experience (like the NIT's), that does not go against the reason for having desktop apps.

A good desktop app can integrate many facets of different apps (via API's etc) to provide a more enhanced mobile experience (which a browser app can do too - think tweetdesk, iGoogle etc, cant think of much now).

Again a good desktop app with Maemo API's van integrate these disparate apps with the Maemo based device data.
Like getting contacts to integrate with Calendar with Google calendar with Facebook contacts with Yahoo Contacts (much like what Pre does I suppose).

If everything was supposed to have been done via browser, why do we cry for a good PIM app on the NIT and not use some online PIM tool itself ?

No sir, a browser based app all the time doesn't cut the mustard all the time.
Well i completely agree that iphone based web apps give a better interface than opening the web browser in the iphone. But as hardware improves like the current omap's it would be better to support the complete web 2.0 and design good websites instead of wasting time and effort for each platform to have an app for that specific application. Then again i understand that the resolution of various mobile devices will not be the same....

So bottom line there are 2 approaches:

1. Get a good hardware with good resolution which can mimic the best desktop expereince

2.If you cant get 1 then you can try the second one... which involves individualized apps.

But i would prefer the first one any day.