View Single Post
hhedberg's Avatar
Posts: 84 | Thanked: 212 times | Joined on Nov 2007 @ Oulu, Finland
#46
Originally Posted by zerojay View Post
Just a question here. I haven't used the new Mauku, but I heard that you're using yellow to denote that a tweet is the start of a thread, correct? Like the 3rd image in your first post?
Actually, no. Yellow means that a tweet is a reply. Blue is the default colour meaning a normal tweet (which may be a start of a thread). But, yes, the idea you had is correct. (The origin of this colour scheme is Jaiku.)

Originally Posted by zerojay View Post
I really don't think that the color is very intuitive to indicate that it's the start of a thread. If I see yellow on a tweet, it makes me immediately think "favorited".
There is a small star on the top-left corner of a favoried tweet in Mauku 2.0 (the star was on right side in old Mauku 0.x).

Originally Posted by zerojay View Post
I think it's a lot more intuitive if you simply use tree view style triangles on the right side (not left as in the image below).
This was considered when designing the new Mauku 2.0 UI. However, there are couple of issues with tree style views in Mauku and Fremantle.

First, the depth of a such tree could be anything. There would be a single first tweet, but after that tweets could be nested very deeply, since replies may have replies also. (Jaiku prevents this and have actually a concept of a thread, but Twitter does not.) If every level were intended, let's say, 20 pixels, only after few levels, the message area would be very narrow.

Secondly, Mauku is built on the concept of timeline. The latest tweets are always on the top of the window. If tweets were grouped into threads, it would be much harder to find latest tweets, since an user had to browse all active threads to read new comments.

Thirdly, the Fremantle HIG does not encourage to use of nested tree style lists. I can see why. Instead, subwindows should be used.

When an user clicks a tweet in Mauku 2.0, a dialog appears (third image in my first post). If a tweet has (known) comments or is a reply, there are options to open a new window with the whole thread of tweets related to the selected tweet (a refererred tweet with the selected comment and other comments or the selected tweet with comments). It is similar, but not the same, functionality than in old Mauku 0.x, and solves the issues listed above.

However, thank you very much for the idea. Keep them coming!

P.S. I have discussed about these things with a professional interaction designer also. Tree view was the first idea he had also. However, after some discussion, he changed his opinion.
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to hhedberg For This Useful Post: