This is healthy.

It's exactly for these view exchanges I posed the Q in the first place. My own views are *obviously* idiosyncratic and draconian and totally out of step. It's why I joined the community, in fact... I can/could see the problems with 'no thanks' but wanted some other viewpoints on it.

So, thanks for the conflicting views These are, in fact, what makes such a site work.

Robust discussion, it's something like a morning swim in a frozen lake...

For the record, I don't know how it would work, I think that as initially suggested it wouldn't, in fact, but please, if you like, keep the ideas coming because I also think the community will evolve and thinking about how to manage that is a good thing.