View Single Post
qole's Avatar
Moderator | Posts: 7,109 | Thanked: 8,820 times | Joined on Oct 2007 @ Vancouver, BC, Canada
#186
First, can we take the Open Source arguments elsewhere? I want to talk about the N900, and the impressions that owners have about it...

Originally Posted by MountainX View Post
What do you think about the posts in this discussion?

http://www.amazon.com/does-this-comp...store=wireless
They sound like tablet owners and Maemo fanboys. I am too. It's hard not to talk like that for us

Originally Posted by sxr71 View Post
You know, it's ironic that you mention e-mail and maps, Those are the two areas of this device that need work. The browser is great and with Adblock it's like a dream come true!

But Maps takes 25-30 seconds to just load and its a pretty cumbersome interface. The compass rotation is slow and stutters. To get to search (which is the number one thing people do with a mapping application) you need to go into 2 levels of menus. Maps is a beta product. It also slows down and freezes for moments.

E-mail actually runs fine. It's snappy and pretty good. But it lacks simple e-mail search. That is a problem. No other platform lacks that now including S60.

I like the fact that you can use keyboard shortcuts as if it were desktop linux. So some things are great, but Maps is unfinished and you will see that when you get yours. E-mail needs a modern feature set.
I actually agree here. Maps and e-mail are the two poorest features on the tablet phone. I am really depending on the Maemo Mapper team to release a Fremantle version soon... I need a useful maps app.

Also, thank goodness I use gmail and so I can just use the full web version on the N900 when I need advanced, 21st century e-mail features like ... search.

Originally Posted by ewan View Post
Since you've used both designs, why would you prefer capacitative? As I understand it, the pros are that it allows multitouch, and it doesn't require any pressure to use, whereas the cons are that you lose precision and the ability to use the screen with anything other than a bare fingertip (so no nails, no stylus)...
I had a very weird and funny experience last night. I find the N900's touch screen to be really nice and responsive, but I let a hardcore iPhone user play with it for a while, and he just couldn't get the photo to pan. It was weird; he was swiping with his finger, and it just wouldn't move. I thought there was something wrong with the N900, so I reached over and made the picture zoom around with no problem. So there really are different ways of interacting with a capacitive and a resistive screen. You just get used to doing it a certain way, and your muscle memory betrays you when you have to do it differently.

He also tried the pinch action to zoom out. No surprise I told him that doesn't work on a resistive screen. But he did like the dial-to-zoom gesture, though, and he thought it was pretty intuitive.
__________________
qole.org --- twitter --- Easy Debian wiki page
Please don't send me a private message, post to the appropriate thread.
Thank you all for your donations!

Last edited by qole; 2009-11-23 at 01:10. Reason: changed "tablet" to "phone" ;)
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to qole For This Useful Post: