View Single Post
Posts: 3,401 | Thanked: 1,255 times | Joined on Nov 2005 @ London, UK
#629
Originally Posted by Flandry View Post
As he put it in the bugzilla, that's a place for "no brainer" reports of things that are clearly broken or not complete. This particular bug report had requests going back and forth, with some pleading not to change it. Hence, it's not a "no brainer" or "friggen basic" (as you so eloquently put it) bug report, but an issue to discuss and vote on. Think of Brainstorm as a place to consider all the possibilities and chose the best one (or more), and the bugzilla to report broken apps.

It doesn't mean that choice of either option won't be the final outcome, but it means we've considered it and it's not just the whim of a few random people.

My personal preference is to have auto-pause, so i'll vote on the brainstorm issue and vote on one or more solutions to that effect if you'll set it up.

Also, FYI there is a community app to do this right now.
The proposed solution covers all the bases, including your preferred option. It's a no brainer. There was no back and forth, a little finesseing yes, but the solution offered in #13 covers all the bases. People asked "do not do this unless you give the option to turn it off" - that's covered too.

The only area of disagreement, if it can be called that, was a comment clarifying whether it should be PAUSE or STOP which isn't particularly relevant to the solution. Anyone reading the bug can work out how to implement the solution. It really is a no brainer, which is what enhancements in the bugzilla are required to be, and this does not need to be debated in Brainstorm (which doesn't even work right now).

Last edited by Milhouse; 2010-01-12 at 08:27.