Thread
:
[Under Consideration] Improving the Maemo 5 phone experience
View Single Post
sjgadsby
2010-01-17 , 12:21
Posts: 5,335 | Thanked: 8,187 times | Joined on Mar 2007 @ Pennsylvania, USA
#
106
Originally Posted by
Texrat
But they ALL have something to do with the original proposal of
improving the phone experience
.
The point is, that original proposal was too broad from the start. It should have been rejected by a Brainstorm moderator with a suggestion given to open a new brainstorm with a more narrow focus.
Finding the sweet spot for problem focus in Brainstorm is going to be like picking topics for term papers back in school.
Propose a topic too narrow, and your teacher will reject it because you'll only get an essay, not a paper, out of it. For us, that's the simple, yay/nay, "Default phone icon should be green, not blue"-type* stuff that belongs in Bugzilla, not Brainstorm.
At the other extreme, the teacher will also reject proposed term paper topics that are too broad, as you'd just wander aimlessly in that book-sized topic and never achieve a real point in your ten pages. In Brainstorm, that's "Make Maemo suck less"-type* stuff. Sure, widespread improvement is a worthy goal, but it needs to be broken into reasonably-sized chunks. Otherwise, as in this case, it becomes impossible to select a solution, implement it, and mark the brainstorm closed, because there are a dozen or more other, unrelated, but probably equally deserving, solutions hanging on.
* Yes, this is a stupid example. It's early, and I'm hoping it's just good enough that my point is conveyed.
__________________
maemo.org profile
Quote & Reply
|
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to sjgadsby For This Useful Post:
edgar2
,
nymajoak
sjgadsby
View Public Profile
Send a private message to sjgadsby
Find all posts by sjgadsby