I have the D2 case but with the push through enclosure. I actually really like it. Looks classy and stays shut well. They are great cases. Really high quality. They come in a gift box inside a felt bag. I use that bag to sit the N900 on when it is just on my desk. (Yep I am fussy so do everything I can to keep it scratch free). The only thing with this case and any horizontal one I imagine is you remove the N900 on an angle rather than pull it straight out as it can flick the unlock slider as it is a snug fit. That is really nit picking though. I could not be happier with it and I avoided the magnet issue with this closure. I customised it with red inner and my initials and this closure. First class guy to deal with also.

I have a clear protector on my N900 to protect the screen. Love that also. Really easy to put on (don't let the water method scare you).

Hope this helps.