View Single Post
Posts: 3,428 | Thanked: 2,856 times | Joined on Jul 2008
#532
Originally Posted by Stskeeps View Post
People should remember this announcement which said:

"This early release comes with an invitation to build variants based on Maemo 5 compatible with existing hardware like the N800 and N810. Maemo SW can't promise commercial quality for such configurations but through maemo.org we are able to collaborate at a community level with technical support, license changes and code."

Our hybris was also that we wanted to start out with a fully open source base instead of cutting corners with closed source things. Also, we went in directions that made us incompatible with Maemo5 for some things as well. So in some ways, in all the organisation build-up and hacking day after day, we forgot to remember about the goal - having a usable OS by the user. In practice, we didn't ask for that much relicensing and those we asked for, we got.

But the invitation still stands, I'd say. If we needed recompiles, I'm sure it would be possible to work it out somehow - especially with the role as distmaster now.
While I appreciate the attempt at being politically correct, and I'm sure your position as an official distmaster has something to do with that... what I took from that was "No."

Which is just the subtle point I was trying to make regarding the "openness" of the Maemo Operating System.

I respect and agree that Nokia is more willing to work with their communities than other manufacturers.. and that the environment in the community, apps, and "root" on device is more open than - say - android... the founding structure of Maemo itself is not fully available.

To grab the sources, and build a working, bootable to desktop version of maemo is not possible, in my understanding - correct?

I love Mer and everything it tried to do.. and hope it does frame into something that is needed in the future, either a stop-gap to M6 for the N900, or just a plain open source replacement to M5 or M6.. either is perfectly wonderful..

But unfortunately Mer (to my understanding) cannot be used as an example of openness like the NITDroid can.. they didn't need to work with Google to get a working port (AFAIK).

Anyway.. this particular topic is off-topic for this thread and belongs in the other one I linked to a few posts back.. You just chimed in at a perfect time .
__________________
If I've helped you or you use any of my packages feel free to help me out.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maintaining:
pyRadio - Pandora Radio on your N900, N810 or N800!
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to fatalsaint For This Useful Post: