I'm not sure i really understand the main idea behind your post, but i'm pretty sure it's not about "can we have a best/worst about the N900". This is why things are hard to find on Talk: threads don't stay on topic. I'm not complaining, i'm just pointing out an example that is easily at hand. Most of the incoherence in Talk is due to the users of Talk. And that's fine, as far as it goes. One thing the community reiterates over and over when the subject comes up is that there are many who don't want Talk to be an office, they want it to be a pub.

At this point you'll probably find the Brainstorm entry to propose and vote on changes to Talk for this year to be the best place for your suggestions. The mods, as i mentioned already, discussed this issue and want to let the community decide through the already-active process of Brainstorm.