I read through a big chunk of the thread and the wiki page. What I really want is a simple cheap pouch for putting the phone in when its in my pocket so it wont get scratched from keys or something like that.

The mertiline pouch looks way too bulky, and the rest look way to expensive for the simple pouch that I want. Does anyone have anything bad to say about just getting one of the dirt cheap ones off of ebay? Anybody use one and have descent success with it?
Velvet
Suede (ignore the apple logo )

Suggestions for a different cheap one?

Edit:
(BTW, I am also searching on dealextreme, so if anyone saw a link there as well)

Thanks