I still see it as valid, warts and all. Yes there is an inherent stumbling block with quantifying various activities but I believe we were making good progress toward finding solutions.

We will never get 100% consensus but really all we need is "good enough" combined with sound judgment to deal with those areas where karma falls short or breaks down. In fact Quim I feel you did a very good job in that regard when it became a sticking point for developer devices.

I would like to see a karma working group formed for MeeGo and nominate my good buddy VDVsx for a slot based on his excellent work and keen understanding of the issues.

EDIT: funny-- I was *just* about to start this topic on the maemo community mailing list.