He's skimming, and still incorrect.

Point out to him that the correction was implemented at some point in production not identified publicly by Nokia-- which would mean some got the fix and some did not. We're not talking a single production lot here.

I really have to wonder about this guy's reading ability and general intelligence. Not impressed thus far.

Bottom line: he's wrong. It's covered by warranty. Keep fighting.

EDIT: I'm betting he didn't read my note to him at the bottom of the comments.