Do you view style of the opening post as something that was intended to create useful discussion? At least personally I find it very hard to read as such, but it is very easy to read it as something that was intended to create friction and bad atmosphere. If you post an opening like that to a forum where a lot of people disagree with what you say, the most probable outcomes would usually be: - thread lock - total silence - whining, whining, whining (as the call, so the echo) I'm not sure which of those would be for the win, but the chances of anything great coming out of it were slim to begin with.