View Single Post
mrojas's Avatar
Posts: 733 | Thanked: 991 times | Joined on Dec 2008
#99
Originally Posted by un-named_user View Post
Others have caught up to Nokia for reasons that are their own doing.

The N95 was a great exmaple of them being able to lead in the market. the iPhone however is an even better example of Nokia not being able to react efficiently or fast enough to changing market conditions.
Nokia's reaction, short-term, was the 5800 XM. Quite a success.

Nokia's main problems stem from the fact of not having a clear product strategy. While its great that they have a bazzilion phones out there. But, that doesn't help if they are in the volume sector as it'll make them no significant profit, period.
They do have a clear product strategy, based in the motto "One size doesn't fit all". It was presented crystal clear in Nokia World, in the presentation of Capital Markets, etc. Just google around for it.

The 3rd world market is in fact the market where the money is. The richest man of the world based his money in mobile in the developing world. Source: http://communities-dominate.blogs.co...th-mobile.html

1.
I suppose simplifying product naming like E,C,X series is a start. But they should look at standardising hardware specs too at some level. I cant imagine the overhead it brings having so many different HW platforms.

They should make tier 1,2,3 level hardware base specs and stick to them.

Why? Cause it helps in sustaining a platform easier.
The whole idea of Qt, of Symbian passed to the Foundation and MeeGo is precisely to make hardware irrelevant, as long is running Qt. In a sense, an OS is a virtualization layer between the HW and SW. That is why I know I can run Windows or Linux software on my PC, independently if its an Acer, Dell, Lenovo, etc.

2.
Nokia has lost the plot on the software side, which is the basic requirement of success these days.

Fragmentation of symbian in silly feature packs is a grave they dug themselves. QT is great but I cant imagine how silly it is for them to expect portability, when I keep reading about meego/symbian specific APIs. Look at the hardware of the next expected Symbian3 device. The screen is nHd intead of Wvga(Meego). and that brings parity within their own product lines & if they stick to the silly nHD, they stand to be inferior very soon.

I don't even want to go the topic of silly product diiferentiation strategies of the N or the E series.
While I don't like the differences between FP's and N and E series, it is clearly working for them (i.e: marketshare just grew, see post above mine).

3.
Ahhh.. the wholy grail.. The UI as everyone keeps bickering about. Functional is what i like, but thats not somwthing that would make me recommend a device to a non-geek friend of mine.

Symbian touch is about the most clunky UI I have ever seen, its like "inconsistencyRus".

Maemo while much better is a case of lacking come common UI design sense. E.g. look at the space wasted by the top bar in all applications, look at the extra step needed to jump between 2 fullscreen browser windows(I installed ShorcutD to mitigate it).

A few essential buttons like the N810 or even android would help. But where is that sense?

Imagine the difficutly if we had potrait mode, try hitting the menu/close button then.
And that is exactly why MeeGo is coming around, and why Symbian^3 and 4 are being designed.

Bottom line.
Nokia needs a consistent, easy and sustainable hardware/software/apps ecosystem or they stand to lag behind in all aspects that matter eventually.
Agreed, and they are working on it. That you have been unable to inform yourself adequately, or disagree with their decisions, doesn't invalidate them.

PS: Before anybody thinks of this as a rant. How many of you would recommend a N900 to a friend? I wont, even though I love mine to bits. In fact somehow I cant think of any Nokia phone except the E71/E72 that I'd ever recommend. Doesn't look good to me at least.
I have done so, and they are happy with their N900's.

[rant]One thing that I hate from Internet, is that anyone is free to spew their opinions, no matter how misinformed they are, and present it as the holy grail of truth. It is something that is happening in the media as well, sadly.[/rant]
__________________
Hola! Soy un Guía de Maemo!.

Vínculos interesantes si nos visitas por primera vez (en inglés): New members say hello , New users start here, Community subforum, Beginners' wiki page, Maemo5 101, Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Si te puedo ayudar con cualquier otra cosa, sólo dilo!

Last edited by mrojas; 2010-04-22 at 21:00.