View Single Post
woody14619's Avatar
Posts: 1,455 | Thanked: 3,309 times | Joined on Dec 2009 @ Rochester, NY
#71
Originally Posted by gerbick View Post
Because it has a marketplace analogous to iTunes Music Store. That's why.
Nobody is talking about media content. The OP (and everyone else here) is talking about DRM for application distribution. You're the only one bringing up media.

Originally Posted by gerbick View Post
That's why I asked the question and never got an answer.
I read well above a 5th grader level and was able to figure out pretty easily that this entire discussion thread is about using DRM to protect application deployment. The comparisons being made are to a marketplace driven app store (like iPhone or Android), not a media download service (like iTunes or Zune).

Originally Posted by gerbick View Post
If you're talking about your own *.exe or *.msi that you've developed... then you will invariably have to use a third party method to protect your app.
Originally Posted by gerbick View Post
Please show me where this is different outside of marketplace type of apps.
You are in violent agreement with each other. The OP is saying we need a marketplace type DRM in place. Another party argued that that particular type of DRM is not needed, citing lots of non-marketplace devices that lack it and still have content developed for them. You're saying the same thing...

In any case, it's not the best argument for the reasons I stated before, volume being the key item. The N900 install base is much smaller than systems that are surviving without a marketplace like system.

Again, I think DRM (for media, for apps, etc) may in fact be an aid in attracting people to a smaller market. But DRM is not needed to bring companies to a platform, there are factors that can outweigh the lack of it. In this specific case, a DRM app delivery system (like OVI) may help draw companies into making software for the device, but it's far from required. As noted there are third party methods for doing this on your own, with or without an OS based framework to build from.

Several business exist that explicitly do not use DRM in their model and are doing just fine. Amazon (and others now) sells raw MP3s these days, no DRM, yet they still do millions a day in MP3 downloads.

And Hitler would like DRM too!

There, it's been said. Can we close this thread now?