View Single Post
Posts: 3,428 | Thanked: 2,856 times | Joined on Jul 2008
#207
Originally Posted by Stskeeps View Post
Random fact: there's 12 packages that don't build for ARM in MeeGo Trunk (fails to compile). We've started patching those and most are trivial build errors. So from a build perspective, we're not much different. On image building side (mic2 support) ARM is a equal member as well now.
Ok, but building != functionality. I still cannot use Wifi easily .


Short story: because it gets a strong ARM offering in MeeGo which is useful for many various reasons, such as platform adaptation. Who'd want to adapt a platform where the ARM reference device works like crap?

Case: Why are we implementing power saving in our N900 kernel when there's no real benefit to developers in this?

Fact: Because we're making a complete hardware adaptation, not a 'developer only' one. A hardware adaptation has to be full to be stable or not be worth anything. Rest of OS, that's another thing.
Ok, understandable. The point is, well, take the very original development G1 released at the Google conference or whatever it was. That phone was not a perfect phone, they only gave out a limited number (which include root out of the box) and were meant for, who? Developers!

That is how I see MeeGo for the N900. The problem? That's not real future for users.


Agreed, this might be a problem, but let's see how we can solve this in a sane manner. To be honest, it should be entirely possible to keep this going. Even at what, 2 man hours a month to check the lights are still on and things are building and getting exported as redistributable bits at repo.meego.com.

Think we're overestimating those few blob's importance. And as I've repeatedly said, I'd like to get rid of them if I could. But as daperl once said:

So, we have them to give a proper user experience. I'm hoping to get them to a redistributable license.
To the first: that talks about meego.. I don't suspect meego to disappear, I suspect nokia to disappear (at least in the reference of the N900). Thus, I think Nokia will get to the point that even 2 man hours a month to make sure the image is built for the N900 isn't worth it.

To the second: I agree with you.. but that's why I don't think it's "over" estimating their importance. Right now they are needed.. it would be great if we could get an open source (or even just openly distributable) BME/3D/whatever binary blob to ensure that no matter where Nokia goes: As long as MeeGo is running we can port the latest and greatest to the N900 (within hardware limitations).

Unfortunately, that's still a huge question mark right now.
__________________
If I've helped you or you use any of my packages feel free to help me out.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maintaining:
pyRadio - Pandora Radio on your N900, N810 or N800!
 

The Following User Says Thank You to fatalsaint For This Useful Post: