View Single Post
Posts: 4,556 | Thanked: 1,624 times | Joined on Dec 2007
#242
Originally Posted by allnameswereout View Post
Hmm, in practice it isn't 'or'. It is a balance between those. If I start my application manager on N900 and select 'all' I am confronted with tons of programs. I get themes, locales, I get 'daemon' and 'UI' versions. All stuff I really do not care about, and it has disengaged my lust to go through the list.

For sure

Makes sense. But a school should have a dumb terminal with Internet access available for you, the customer.

You can get the same functionality by SSHing into a Debian machine, or using say NX to get a remote X Window desktop. WiFi on a N8x0 would be suffice for this.

Given most people in Western society have an always-on connection they could easily run some embedded hardware and have 24/7 access to this. A SheevaPlug, for example, costs only $100.
Yeah, but as I said it's different for each use case. For example, running that configuration means increased power consumption at home (or rather my fiancee's apartment nowadays).

It also assumes that I have a constant connection to the internet (*cough* take the DC Metro system *cough*). And what I meant by school is not the school's system, but my own systems I use for doing school work so it's not something they could provide anyway.

Anyway, the Maemo platform is a bit unique since its main problem (outside of Nokia's failure to support it) is a small userbase from being locked into one manufacturer (and also one device). With that you'll have less interest from commercial developers and its often easier to port or use an optimize app as a non-commercial developer than to redo an application's UI for the device. Heck, I'm surprised we got Angry Birds before Android did. At this point the only commercial benefit for developing for Maemo would be developing in QT (for future compatibility to Symbian and Meego).

Anyway, back on topic (on Apps). True but themes, locales, daemons (well I would argue daemons are often just as useful as apps but that's IMO) are just a subset of apps. Out of the entire Android market, even if the UI isn't optimized for the Samsung Tab, there are going be useful applications that can be used until a suitable replacement comes along. Then as developers either update their app, or competitors come along, you then get optimized Android apps for a tablet form factor. And unlike the Maemo platform, Android has the environment for that to happen.

Though interestingly Google has pretty much said that 2.2 is not for tablets, and that any tablets coming out now (using 2.2) will not have marketplace access. The Tab sneaks on by since its not considered a tablet by Google (screen size wise). So they are aware of the whole optimization issue.
__________________
Originally Posted by ysss View Post
They're maemo and MeeGo...

"Meamo!" sounds like what Zorro would say to catherine zeta jones... after she slaps him for looking at her dirtily...

Last edited by Laughing Man; 2010-09-15 at 03:11.
 

The Following User Says Thank You to Laughing Man For This Useful Post: