It's an interesting argument but the facts don't change. I can't speak for other countries, but here in America the education system does what it can to make sure that a student has the resources they need to do their coursework, either through student labs or appropriate discounts, so there is simply no need for students to steal.

Now, your assertion is that those who have pirated in the past aren't one to judge. There's a difference between condemning actions and condemning people. I think discussions have been generally civil (certainly not out of hand as things can easily go on the internet). I see nothing with an exchange of ideas, that is in fact why the question was posed, was it not?

I used to back-in-the day, before the days I bought PKZip, so I understand why people do it. It doesn't mean though that its right or that I should encourage or condone it.

You can disagree with someone without judging them.