View Single Post
Posts: 138 | Thanked: 103 times | Joined on Jan 2010 @ Southern Germany
#9
Originally Posted by burmashave View Post
As an example of what I'm talking about, I currently use Sylpheed-Claws for my email. The packaged Maemo email app. would never fit my needs, and were it the only email app. for Maemo, I would not own an N900. The Sylpheed-Claws version for Maemo is -- as near as I can tell -- roughly as powerful as its desktop companion. If you haven't used Sylpheed-Claws, it is one of the most feature rich email clients for *nix. Nevertheless, I have an easy time using it on my N900, although I use a stylus.
For me Claws is one of those examples which describe the problem of the Maemo platform and the N900 in particular. Advertised as a tablet it is able to operate like a desktop PC however its form factor is more of the phone type.
If you use it as a PC then you need the stylus to eg. navigate through small size drop down menus or use keyboard shortcuts. If you use it like a (i)phone you definitely donīt want that. In this case the app is either clever laid out to provide a quick touchscreen navigation or functionality is reduced and adapted.
This is my problem with Claws for example- the functionaliy I use mobile is a rather limited subset of what Claws provides and the layout (though it can be adapted) is imho not very suitable for such a small screen. Sure I have some whishes which the built-in mail client should provide, encryption and signing is one of them.
However it is sufficient to quickly check mail from several imap accounts and respond/forward those.

Regarding TaskCoach: I used it a lot lately. And I found out that the power of the app can only be applied on larger screen layouts. Take the various views you can have, the category window, timeline, etc. Most people will have their personal task layouts combined from several views on one display which you can not bring to a mobile device without rendering it unusable. Imho.
Therefore I support the approach the iPhone app was going. A different standalone application compatible with the XML file format which focuses on the primary purpose of the app- providing a glance about tasks, editing them, synchronize them. All in a layout which considers usability issues on mobile devices.
Because this is the use case I believe most people will apply mobile: A quick glance what is to do today, tomorrow, next week, what is open, what is completed and adapt the progress, then write it back to the master.
Keep it small, simple but powerful.

Last edited by ofels; 2010-11-16 at 09:20.
 

The Following User Says Thank You to ofels For This Useful Post: