View Single Post
nicolai's Avatar
Posts: 1,637 | Thanked: 4,424 times | Joined on Apr 2009 @ Germany
#102
Originally Posted by qgil View Post
The OS development is happening at MeeGo and there you have a collection of open source applications being developed as well. It's up to vendors to take these, take other free software apps or take none.
I don't understand, how is this related to the text you quoted?
Originally Posted by qgil View Post
When it comes to product development the guys deciding on the Nokia investments and the plans to convert them into benefits conclude that having a Nokia proprietary layer is better for business than not having it. Looking at the market and at the business results of companies shipping devices with 100% free software I can't deny that they have a point.
I can understand this points, but 100%free software doesn't mean
100% open-source-community-based-crap or semi-professional software.
Originally Posted by qgil View Post
And note that some of the pre-installed apps in Maemo 5 are open source or have a relatively thin closed UX layer on top of open application engines. So it's not that black and white either.
Yes, but it is this thin layer that stands in our way. A thin layer
wouldn't be so bad, but there are some terrible bugs.

calendar application:
forgets task alarms
has senseless alarm presets.
mediaplayer widget play button doesn't work always.
camera applications exposure setting does not work with manual iso setting.

So you have this thin layer but some parts
just don't work.

We don't know how long nokia supports maemo5 or
if there will be another update.
Is there hope to get bugs fixed?
And (I don't really dare to ask) feature requests?

Another probem is, nokias applications aren't great they aren't worthfull to protect but they are well integrated. And this advantage
is inaccessible for the community. We can never fully replace these well intergrated applications with our owns.

It is just sad to see what could be possible with the great N900 hardware, the Maemo5 OS and this community.

nicolai
 

The Following 12 Users Say Thank You to nicolai For This Useful Post: