View Single Post
vkv.raju's Avatar
Posts: 402 | Thanked: 451 times | Joined on Dec 2007 @ India
#141
Originally Posted by gerbick View Post
It's not that the US is the only place that creates standards for their phones. Case in point, TD-SCDMA in China. I could probably conjure up a few others.
I am from India. Here it is not like we are only using GSM. We have CDMA (may be 1/3rd, I am not sure) too. But it costs an absolute "0" for anyone to change carriers. The concept of people getting locked to a carrier is infact an unheard thing to majority of the people here. Because of this (NO carrier lock), the pricing is always competitive. Indian Govt has done its fair part by subsidizing telecom license prices here and as a result, the benefit is directly being passed to the end consumer. The mobile revolution in India is a case study in itself. US can take a look at it if it wants.

And the US government is not the only place prone to lobbying. I fear that you paint the US in a way that makes it so unique without acknowledging that what you state happens in basically every other country in one way or another.
I am afraid I am not painting anything. It is a fact. US is a businessman's playground. It brings both good and bad. If you accept the good, then you have ideally voted to accept the bad also.


How do you care to actually pay for all of those changes? It's already one of the more expensive places to own a phone.
Why should everyone in the US pay extra charges to the carrier? Is it not the Govt's responsibility to subsidize these things if it is being used by so many people and if it can make things better for so many people and if it gets easy on so many peoples pockets? Don't they spend money on NASA and those moon missions? Oh and those nuclear weapons?

I will say one thing... the so-called death grip is really important if you're a Nokia fan in the US. Otherwise, people really don't migrate as much - even when it was a more even playing field when everybody was CDMA or TDMA. I unlocked a Cincinnati Bell Nokia 7160 to work on Suncom's network without incident. Didn't net me one damn discount.
Didn't understand actually. Sorry for my bad english.

Same applies now. Anyway, until the FCC forces all of the carriers to play fair, bow down and play nice with the same GSM frequencies like all of the other countries of the world; we'll continue to have this fractured, out-dated system that is easier to discuss how it should be fix than it truly is to fix it.
I wish good luck for you. But I doubt the path will be so easy & clear. There will be some catch somewhere. But again, I honestly wish good luck for the people in US. You have been enough cheated already. (I am not being satiric here).


Simply stated; talk is real cheap. The fix will not be cheap.
The question here is, is the fix needed? If yes, then why would you worry about the cost? US spends so much money for so many other useless things and I am very very sure it has enough money (read: debt) to spend for this also.

Disclaimer: My intent is only for a healthy debate. If you feel my statements hurt your love towards your country, then please accept my apologizes. I will not comment on this topic any further.
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to vkv.raju For This Useful Post: