View Single Post
joppu's Avatar
Posts: 780 | Thanked: 855 times | Joined on Sep 2009 @ Helsinki, Finland
#49
Originally Posted by shazosbourne View Post
I am happy that you have made additional icons which suit your taste. As was said to me when I started this pack, you can't please all the people all the time. Taste is purely personal.

Thanks for adding yours.
Well, excuse me, but those icons are straight from the Faenza icon pack, and unlike yours, they are scaled correctly (Which you seem to be incapable to do do). I may come off as blunt, but if the only contribution for this icon set is to copy someone else's work and rescale and package the icons, you at least better do it properly. So I don't buy this ******** about "additional icons" since I actually went and fixed something for you which you couldn't do properly in the first place. If badly scaled and disfigured icons are your taste, I can't really help you, but for everybody else's benefit, proper icons might be more appealing.

Also, your battery icons didn't even match the ones in Feanza icon theme itself, they lacked the gradient of the green part of the battery itself therefore looking like you had re-drawn them with MS PAINT or equivalent.

I'm not even mentioning the fuzzy scaling work on other icons, but they didn't stand out like a sore numb like the battery one, so I let it slide.


Originally Posted by shazosbourne View Post
Taste is purely personal.
Uh, there are two things that irritate me when it comes to design, the design itself and technical execution. I can't really complain about design (eg. "taste") since everyone has their own. But I can do complain about the execution. And I can also offer my help on that. Which I in fact did, but I apparently got rejected. So, poor technical execution != taste.

Last edited by joppu; 2011-02-09 at 11:38.