View Single Post
Posts: 2,225 | Thanked: 3,822 times | Joined on Jun 2010 @ Florida
#743
Originally Posted by freemangordon View Post
I agree wih you, but the sad fact is that patch preventig QT apps to segfault when launched in portrait is not enough. For some reason QT on n900 seems like not tested at all in portrait mode. An example - hildon specific buttons ( those dark grey ones like "save", "done", ... ) appear with no background when launched in portrait. Who knows what else but before that is fixed there is no point to enable global portrait mode. This will only make lots of noise from users wanting to be spoonfed (and I don't mean like you).
Hmmm... I'll be honest with you, I don't have that many Qt programs on my N900, but the one's I've tested this on, I don't seem to see any problems (I've tested FastSMS, and HealthCheck.)

I do see a problem with HealthCheck, something about certain images not found according to an error it prints to X-Term, but it seems to appear regardless of whether it's launched in portrait mode or not.

What Qt apps do you have this error in? I'd be happy to test further.

Either way, I'm sorry, but I don't get the logic of that. It's basically saying "it's not going to be perfectly supporting everything, so we shouldn't include it at all". By the same reasoning, why bother doing anything? Why bother developing a system-wide portrait keyboard, if portrait support didn't yet exist everywhere? Etc, etc.

It just really seems like a very moot point. Portrait support has been wanted since this phone came out. If it's not implemented globally, it works peacemeal like it does now, but always with manual auto-rotate, etc. If it IS implemented globally, it still works peacemeal, but it works for a lot more things, and it works automatically for a lot more programs where it didn't work before. The ones it works glitch-ish-ly for, it still effectively doesn't completely work for, but there's a bunch of programs the usability of which gets increased.

I mean, really, if you look at all the programs that the N900 has, how many of them are actually in Qt? And most of those are at least made to work in portrait mode, if not to be launched in portrait mode. Having global auto-rotation would be wonderfully useful, and even if you're right and those Qt apps have problems with it, it's not hard to mentally remember that a few of your phone's apps shouldn't be launched in portrait mode - far more convenient, it is, then clicking some shortcutd mapped key to use Ctrl+Shift+R, let alone manually entering that combination.
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Mentalist Traceur For This Useful Post: