I just tested on my phone to double check. Regardless of being a private call or a call from one of your "blocked contacts" all that happens is that I see a "yellow banner" (may have a different background color depending on your theme) for a few seconds saying something like "Crochik MyContacts Rejected call from ....."

The call does not show on my call log at all. I would actually prefer to have the call registered on my log like someone else asked before.

Few notes:
The call r

• Call Reject hasn't changed since the first time it was included on mycontacts.
• The process is exact the same of "private calls" and "black listed numbers"

I can't imagine what could be the issue on your phone. Do you have any other applications installed that monitor incoming calls to assign custom ring tones and/or block calls?