maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N810 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=28)
-   -   My review... (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=20431)

Scythe 2008-05-26 03:16

My review...
 
So, I purchased my n810 on Monday, and received it Wendsday for a trip up to Maine. I was going to wait for the WiMax edition, but at the rate of Xohm and Clearwire it looks like it'll be out by the end of the year. That's way too long for me to wait, so I just decided "it was time". Anyway, so I bought the n810 off of Buy.com, which shipped it instantly and looked great. I ripped it out of its packaging, let it charge up, and then flashed it first thing with the latest firmware using my Ubuntu laptop.

Part of my decision in getting the n810 was GPS -- cause I'll be driving from Virginia to Maine and back. Secondly, to hold me over so I don't need to carry my 3lb laptop with me everywhere. So, come Thursday evening off I went with the fiance to Maine -- with only the n810 leading the way. I set it to skip all toll's and it did just that. As we're driving, I did manage to miss a turn and it quickly rerouted and got me back on track. It got us all the way up there in one piece, and I couldn't have asked for more. In fact, it navigated far better than my friends Garmin he rented with his rental car (so we used the n810 to find the Maine Mall, etc for the rest of the trip).

For the remainder of the 3 days, I used the n810 to check email and do general surfing/news reading. It accomplished it all with ease. On the last day some of our friends met up with us (we were all at a wedding), and many of them were very interested in the n810 as far as replacing their palm pilots. I had to explain to them it wasn't a cell phone of course, and that many/most of the applications are open source and free for download, etc. Overall, they seemed very impressed. One of the comments that I got was that one of my friends loved the fact that he could actually hold it in his hands, and it felt like he was actually holding something (I guess his palm pilot is way too light -- which I never knew was a problem).

On the way home I took toll roads, and managed to get back successfully once again. I did hit one snag when we went through a still-developing neighborhood since the waypoints are a bit dated, but overall no problems at all that I wouldn't have expected from any other GPS systems.

Overall, I love my n810 and fully expect to use it to its full potential. My friend intends on buying one for Skyping in Hawaii as well.

My one complaint: we need video hardware acceleration. Lagging on a simplistic youtube video was slightly disheartening. Overall though, I'm impressed :)


Edit: GPS lock times around 15-45 seconds.

GeneralAntilles 2008-05-26 03:18

Re: My review...
 
http://www.internettablettalk.com/fo...ad.php?t=12004

Scythe 2008-05-26 03:29

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 185838)

Sorry I misplaced my post by creating a new thread, however mods have the ability to "join" threads. So, being an asshat off the bat is a little unnecessary.

gemniii42 2008-05-26 12:12

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scythe (Post 185841)
Sorry I misplaced my post by creating a new thread, however mods have the ability to "join" threads. So, being an asshat off the bat is a little unnecessary.

Ah yes, start posting with a foul mouth which is undoubtedly below a brain that does not investigate.

There are no "mods"

Scythe 2008-05-26 15:56

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gemniii42 (Post 185906)
Ah yes, start posting with a foul mouth which is undoubtedly below a brain that does not investigate.

There are no "mods"

Anyone who uses message boards would fully expect there to be. I didn't have a foul mouth, it just so happens that I've yet to read a positive post from GeneralAntilles (just use search ;) ).

We call people like that: "trolls" -- typically the type of user to run newbies off a board.

GeneralAntilles 2008-05-26 15:59

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scythe (Post 185950)
Anyone who uses message boards would fully expect there to be. I didn't have a foul mouth, it just so happens that I've yet to read a positive post from GeneralAntilles (just use search ;) ).

I posted a thread where the N810 reviews go, directing you to the place where your review would likely get the most views. Hardly "asshattery". It's a thin-skinned world these days. :\

Scythe 2008-05-26 16:03

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 185951)
I posted a thread where the N810 reviews go, directing you to the place where your review would likely get the most views. Hardly "asshattery". It's a thin-skinned world these days. :\

Precisely, however -- you can't exactly delete your thread here and move it there. Hence, where a mod would typically step in. I understand my wrongdoing, but making a blatant comment without a way of fixing the situation is rather "asshat" like. Especially with your post count.

It's like telling someone who just asked a question to "search for it first".

GeneralAntilles 2008-05-26 16:13

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scythe (Post 185953)
Precisely, however -- you can't exactly delete your thread here and move it there. Hence, where a mod would typically step in. I understand my wrongdoing, but making a blatant comment without a way of fixing the situation is rather "asshat" like. Especially with your post count.

I'm afraid we've got a bit of a chicken and the egg conundrum here. If you knew it was the wrong thing to do, then why did you do it? If you didn't know, then how would you ever learn if somebody didn't point it out to you?

Besides, I made no "comment" I simply posted a URL, you decided to add a "comment" in your own mind that. Did you consider that I may have just been pointing you to the place where people would get the most usage out of your review, thus increasing the benefit derived from your effort?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scythe (Post 185953)
It's like telling someone who just asked a question to "search for it first".

If you don't discourage wasteful thread creation, then it'll spiral out of control (well, actually, we're already way past that point) and you'll end up with a forum filled to the brim with the same things over and over and over (just like we have now!) and drive away a large number of core contributers (just like we've already done!).

gemniii42 2008-05-26 16:35

Re: My review...
 
Scythe -
And actually, since this thread is hijacked, one of the reasons some of us try to correct newbies is because hopefully pretty soon (Oct?) the WiMax version will be released and a ton of new posters will jump in all asking similar questions without looking at existing threads. The board does not really need 50 threads of "what's the best software for me?", "does this thing teleport?", "gee - I got one everybody pay attention to me".

Around last Christmas the signal to noise ratio approached 1 to infinity.

And
Quote:

It's like telling someone who just asked a question to "search for it first".
is often a good response.

geneven 2008-05-26 16:44

Re: My review...
 
We certainly don't need a review like the one posted here, with nothing but good things said about the N810, its usefulness and how impressed the posters friends are. Why, Nokia could buy good publicity like that for a couple hundred thousand dollars -- why would we want it posted for free here? Especially not up at the top, in a high visibility area!! The least that could be done would be to bury it in a lot of other reviews so not many people see it!

IcelandDreams 2008-05-26 17:03

Re: My review...
 
Wow, how does a simple review post draw so much trouble? Pretty innocent I thought so perhaps I'm missing the crime here. Hate to see what happens if it was a negative post. oh, wait....

crabolsky 2008-05-26 17:22

Re: My review...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 185951)
I posted a thread where the N810 reviews go, directing you to the place where your review would likely get the most views. Hardly "asshattery". It's a thin-skinned world these days. :\

Exactly. There weren't any snide remarks made Scythe, so why so quick to criticize?

That being said, it would behoove all that frequent this board to squash this sort of situation quickly. I already feel like I have been robbed of time that could of been spent on some worthwhile reading.

I know it would be a full time job to keep up with correcting new users, but a quick pre-formatted response that gives the correct direction (ie please post your comments here and then delete the offending post) would help all involved.

joepagiii 2008-05-26 18:36

Re: My review...
 
sometimes i want clarification..so i pm the most likely people who may be able to answer....never heard if thats a bad thing to do...

EIPI 2008-05-26 18:50

Re: My review...
 
I PM'd someone once (cold-call), and I got a pretty polite, but stern reply back. Basically, the other person's point of view was that my question would have been better for the community if it were open and in the forums, rather than within a PM that he checks infrequently. Although this individual was the key person to answer the question, I understood his point. PM'ing people only benefits you, but not the others in the community. Furthermore, it's a burden to the individual that you are PM'ing - he is the only one that can reply back, whereas as a forum post, some newbie may have the answer that you are looking for, and they can to reply to it. Just a few thoughts based upon my experience in this area. YMMV, of course. I realize that we're completely off topic from the original post...

munky261 2008-05-26 21:30

Re: My review...
 
myself i really dont care how many times a question has been asked in different threads , if i can help the poster i answer his question to the best of my ability , if i cant i just move on.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:30.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8